Dr Watson states, "I always smoke 'ship's' myself" Anyone care to define 'ship's' which later becomes Ship's without quotes and a capital "S"? Over a half-century ago, a Sherlockian with the first name of Sherry ploughed this ground, but the definitive answer remains elusive. Are you up to the challenge?

 


Comments

Roxie
07/01/2013 6:58pm

Scrolling through bits and pieces found for me by Google, I discovered that the British Navy supplied tobacco to its sailors in the form of ropes, which could be either chewed and smoked. The tobacco would be preserved with rum.

From this I would go one step further on my own and speculate that Watson smoked a rum-flavored tobacco with a flavor similar to that supplied to sailors.

Sounds like it might smell fairly nice, assuming one likes the smell of rum.

Reply
Buttons
07/02/2013 1:07pm

Roxie . . . Good information. Thank you. To chew, sailors bit off a "hank" or a short bit of rope. To smoke, they "picked" or shredded the rope of tobacco into a small pile for their pipe bowl.

Now we have to deal with the "ship's" and the Ships dichotomy.

Reply
Dash
07/02/2013 4:33pm

An inquiry to the George Arents Collection on Tobacco at the New York Public Library revealed they had almost nothing on ship's tobacco per se. Librarian Kyle Triplett kindly located the following:
Dodd, J. "A Glimpse of the manners and customs of the hill tribes of Formosa." Journal of the Straits Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society 15 (1885): 69-78. Quote:
" ...Tobacco grows wild in many parts of the country inhabited by the savages, and in Chinese territory it is cultivated to a large extent in certain districts. The savages simply sun-dry it, then rub it in their hands and place it in their pipes. In this form it is very mild. Foreigners make it into blocks by placing the leaves one above the other; a little water is then sprinkled over them, sometimes a dash of rum, the leaves are then pressed into a compact block, or are compressed into a circular shape about the size of the wrist and tapering to a point at both ends. Tobacco made in this form is tied round tightly together with rope, and is a very good substitute for what is called ship's tobacco. Native-grown tobacco, has been often prepared in this way by sailors on board British gunboats visiting Tamsui, and has been much appreciated by every one fond of a pipe."

He stated that there may be further references in other books, but that I would need to come to New York and research them myself (put on the to-do list).

So, ship's appears to have been a densely-packed rope or twist of tobacco as Roxie described. This is reflected in Antarctic Adventure: Scott's Northern Party by Sir Robert E. Priestly (London: Unwin, 1914; NY: Dutton, 1915), p. 187, where he writes that "large quantities of leaf tobacco as well as some plug and cut tobacco had been landed. The latter, however, had run out entirely...and...some of the smokers were unable to smoke pure ship's tobacco...." So, ship's was neither leaf, plug or cut, but something different.

As far as the smell, Roxie, it appears to have been pretty awful. Priestley describes it as "vile" (p. 188) and states (p. 127) that "ship's tobacco has always been my greatest enemy on a sledge journey, and has on more than one occasion made me lose a meal...."

Reply
Pippin
07/02/2013 5:01pm

What awesome pieces of information. I wonder if Holmes smiled to himself at Watson's braggadocio and surmised that the doctor's experience was a bit of nautical hazing by the crew of the Orontes?

Reply
Dash
07/02/2013 11:09pm

And I wonder if Watson smiled to himself when Holmes said, "You still smoke the Arcadia mixture of your bachelor days, then" and Watson replied, "No, ship's, Sherlock!"

Reply
Pippin
07/03/2013 9:23am

+1

Reply



Leave a Reply